Stephen Miller, the Jewish Outlier at the Heart of the White House
Days after the Republicans lost both houses of Congress, Donald Trump made Stephen Miller, the architect of his anti-immigration policy, his White House chief of staff. Returning to a portrait she published a year ago, Jo-Ann Mort looks at Miller through the eyes of those he grew up among — his family, his childhood rabbi, the Reform movement in which he was raised — and asks what his rise means for American Jews: can the memory of having been immigrants still bind a community that agrees on little else?
After the Republicans’ midterm defeat cost them control of Congress, Donald Trump appointed Stephen Miller White House chief of staff, giving him one of the most influential posts in his administration. It is worth recalling who Stephen Miller is – this far-right ideologue whose Jewish family fled pogroms and found refuge in the United States, and who went on to become the architect of immigration policies that would have shut the door on families like his.
In October 2025, I published a profile of Miller in the British magazine Prospect: “What happened to Stephen Miller?” I begin here with a revised and abridged version of that profile, then turn to his recent promotion and the questions it raises, particularly for American Jews.
The Making of an Ideologue
Stephen Miller has the unusual dishonor of having an informational bio on the “Extremist Files” section on the website of the civil rights non-profit the Southern Poverty Law Center… Miller was the architect of the draconian anti-immigrant programme during Trump’s first term. In Trump’s second, he has returned with a more powerful position and an even more vengeful spirit, not only against immigrants—legal and illegal—but against anyone who opposes the Trump regime.
Few figures in Washington have rallied so many opponents against themselves. The Democratic party leadership is among his enemies, but he also hates all Democratic party officeholders simply because they are Democrats. He opposes any judges trying to uphold a fraying American constitutional framework who rule against the administration and activists seeking to defend a similarly fraying democracy…
Even former Republicans have turned against him. George Conway, once a Republican strategist (whose ex-wife Kellyanne Conway was an adviser in the first Trump White House), recently said, for instance, that Miller was less like Joseph Goebbels—the Nazi propagandist whom some people have compared him to—and more like Heinrich Himmler, the head of the SS responsible for implementing the “Final Solution”.
His rise to this position was patiently built. Now forty years old, he held his first jobs, after graduating from Duke University, with prominent congressional representatives, first the former Republican congresswoman Michele Bachmann and later Jeff Sessions, a former senator who was attorney general briefly in the first Trump term. But his convictions had taken shape earlier: in college (as a philosophy major), Miller used a bi-weekly column, titled “Miller Time”, in the university’s student paper to rail against feminism, the culture wars, left-wing “propaganda” and immigrants. “Why aren’t our airports, borders or ports secure? … Why are there 3,000,000 people in the United States who have overstayed their visas? Why isn’t the murder of 3,000 people enough to shake us out of our apathy?” he wrote in 2006, in a piece about the 9/11 attacks.
In the years that followed, Miller immersed himself in [the far-right news site] Breitbart News and the newly pungent and powerful right-wing media networks. He joined the first Trump White House as a speechwriter and spent the intervening years before his return promoting and fostering non-profits in communications and the legal right-wing ecospheres in order to create a support system for Trump’s re-election. Miller headed up the conservative legal activist group America First Legal (though he has no law degree) and was an adviser for the notorious Trumpian blueprint Project 2025.
An ideology that would have made his own story impossible

The Trump administration has offered us several windows into family angst, most notably from the heirs of the late liberal senator Robert F Kennedy, as his son proceeds to dismantle the American health system. But the Miller family hasn’t shied away from sharing their profound pain concerning Stephen, either. I suspect that Miller and his wife and children are no longer invited to break bread around a family holiday table.
“I grieve what you’ve become, Stephen. And I grieve what I’ve lost because of it.”
Recently, a first cousin of Miller’s from his father’s side posted a damning attack against him on social media. “I grieve what you’ve become, Stephen. And I grieve what I’ve lost because of it. I grieve your children I will never meet. I grieve the future family you’ve stolen from me by choosing a path so filled with cruelty that I cannot, and will not, be a part of it. I will never knowingly let evil into my life, no matter whose blood it carries—including my own,” she wrote. “We celebrate holidays each year with the reminder to stand up and say, ‘never again.’ But what you are doing breaks that sacred promise. It breaks everything we were taught.”
This followed an earlier post from Miller’s maternal uncle, David S. Glosser, a retired neuropsychologist. He displayed similar heartbreak and confusion about how someone raised in a liberal, intellectual Santa Monica West Los Angeles milieu could be working against US democracy. Like so many other US Jews, Miller’s family were grateful that in the last century they had arrived from pogroms in Russia to a democratic America. Glosser’s post was made during the first Trump term, when the president and Miller both defended the neo-Nazis marching in Charlottesville, Virginia who chanted “Jews will not replace us”. Trump said at the time that the protesters included “some very fine people.”
Miller’s uncle counselled: “The Glossers came to the US just a few years before the fear and prejudice of the ‘America first’ nativists of the day closed US borders to Jewish refugees. Had Wolf-Leib waited, his family likely would have been murdered by the Nazis along with all but seven of the 2,000 Jews who remained in Antopol. I would encourage Stephen to ask himself if the chanting, torch-bearing Nazis of Charlottesville, whose support his boss seems to court so cavalierly, do not envision a similar fate for him.”
“The actions that you now encourage President Trump to take make it obvious to me that you didn’t get my, or our, Jewish message.”
There is probably nothing more central to the liberal and mainstream American Jewish experience than the history of being immigrants and of having the opportunity to thrive and prosper in a US that welcomed them. In a 2018 Rosh Hashanah sermon Miller’s childhood rabbi, Rabbi Comess-Daniels, preached: “Honestly, Mr. Miller, you’ve set back the Jewish contribution to making the world spiritually whole through your arbitrary division of these desperate people. The actions that you now encourage President Trump to take make it obvious to me that you didn’t get my, or our, Jewish message.”
Indeed, Miller has abandoned his liberal Jewish upbringing, making a political home instead among the Christian—and largely white—right wing. As a featured speaker at the recent memorial for murdered Maga activist Charlie Kirk, Miller proclaimed that enemies of the Maga movement “have nothing”, while conservatives “are on the side of God”. This ideology hails, too, from someone who heavily influenced Miller and another Jewish right-wing ideologue—the recently deceased David Horowitz, who swerved jaggedly from the Marxist left (when he founded the 1960s magazine Ramparts), to the far right. Both deny that Trump lost the 2020 election and Horowitz, like Miller, was a warrior against any kind of diversity and inclusion.
Miller’s profile on the Southern Poverty Law Center’s website sits among those of neo-Nazis, skinheads and Holocaust deniers—an extraordinary place to be for someone who wields so much power in the White House. His profile says: “Stephen Miller is credited with shaping the racist and draconian immigrant policies of President Trump, which include the zero-tolerance policy, also known as family separation, the Muslim ban and ending the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program. Miller has also ‘purged’ government agencies of civil servants who are not entirely loyal to his extremist agenda.”
For most Americans, being included in such a listing would be a profound stain. For Miller, it’s possible he would regard it as a badge of honour. Meanwhile, in October 2025, there was already a dangerous, unprecedented and heightened military presence on America’s streets. Economic sectors are hurting as a result of anti-immigrant policies. According to the National Immigration Law Center, “Mass deportations are forecast to reduce our nation’s Gross Domestic Product (GDP, a measure of the overall economy) by more than 7 per cent in the next three years—greater than the damage to the US economy during the Great Recession from 2007 to 2009.” Students are staying out of schools in immigrant-heavy neighbourhoods, fearful of ICE raids on educational establishments or what will happen to their parents while they are gone. The stakes for American democracy are high. What happens in these cities, and how far the courts will allow Miller to achieve his goal, will reverberate for many years to come.
More and more power: from adviser to chief of staff

And now, one year after I published that profile, Stephen Miller is back — and big time. He moves from his already-powerful perch in the Trump White House to being in charge of it: on 6 November, Trump named him chief of staff, replacing Susie Wiles.1 His appointment was a bit surprising, if only because Trump and the Republican Party lost so massively in the midterm elections that a sane analyst would have expected the President to put a conciliator, not a flame-thrower, in charge. So much for sane analysis.
Indeed, American public broadcasting reported this about Miller: “During a 2023 spike in illegal border crossings, Miller described migrants as invaders, even though many were escaping poverty and violence in their home countries. He told Fox News (the right-wing channel): ‘We are being conquered…We have millions of people coming in from different cultures and different ways of living and different belief systems.’”
Miller, sounding much like Le Pen and her party, was quoted saying that “a generation from now,” people “will not know the country that they are living in. These consequences are permanent. Unless there’s massive large-scale deportations by the millions, it will be irrevocable.”
“For a nation born of immigrants like the United States — and for American Jews, all of whom come from some type of immigrant background — the dissonance is spectacular.”
For a nation born of immigrants like the United States — and for American Jews, all of whom come from some type of immigrant background — the dissonance is spectacular. But more than that, this was one of the issues on which Trump lost control of the US Congress. Voters, some of whom had supported Trump in his own re-election bid, voted his party out partly because of the extreme and truly hateful measures used against immigrants in our American streets.
Jewish tradition of relationship to immigration

The largest religious Jewish movement in America (and the one where Miller was bar mitzvahed), the Reform Movement (Union for Reform Judaism), puts it this way: “Welcoming, caring for, not oppressing, and even loving the stranger, or immigrant, are core parts of Jewish tradition, together mentioned 36 times in the Torah. Leviticus commands, ‘The stranger who resides with you shall be to you as one of your citizens; you shall love them as yourself, for you were strangers in the land of Egypt’ (19:33-34). Our own people’s history as ‘strangers’ reminds us of the many struggles faced by immigrants today.”
After Border Patrol agents shot and killed Alex Pretti, an intensive-care nurse who was engaged in lawful protest against the Trump administration’s hardline immigration policies, in Minneapolis on 24 January 2026, Miller posted on social media that the 37-year-old Minneapolis resident was a “domestic terrorist” and an “assassin” who had “tried to murder federal agents.” (Three days later, Miller admitted that the federal officers in Minneapolis “may not have been following” protocol.)
The perspective of a divided community united against him

In December 2019, during Trump’s first term, 25 Jewish Democratic members of the House demanded Miller’s dismissal “for disseminating the views of hate groups supportive of white supremacy and virulently anti-immigrant tropes” — a demand that, of course, went unheeded by Trump. “The recently released emails show Stephen Miller trafficking the views of white supremacist hate groups that espouse a repugnant and extreme anti-immigrant agenda,” said the letter’s co-leads Congressman Schneider and Congresswoman Wasserman Schultz (both of whom were re-elected to Congress in this cycle). “These hateful views have no place in our government, much less just steps from the Oval Office.2 At this time of rising antisemitism, xenophobia, racism and white supremacy, we must forcefully call out and refuse to accept intolerance or hate anywhere within our government.”
Importantly, the letter writers also rejected the White House’s claim that criticism of Miller was “clearly a form of anti-Semitism”: “Weaponizing anti-Semitism is incredibly dangerous.” A significantly broad alliance of Jewish organizations joined together to demand his firing in the previous Trump administration, including the Anti-Defamation League3, which has grown increasingly conservative in the last few years.
“Miller’s persona and policies appear to be what can unite a fairly disunited organized Jewish community.”
So far, this broad condemnation hasn’t happened, but I suggest giving it a little time. Miller’s persona and policies appear to be what can unite a fairly disunited organized Jewish community, except for the ultra-Orthodox and far right-wing organizations like the Zionist Organization of America which represent a tiny, tiny portion of American Jewry and will stick with Trump and his appointees until he leaves office. Indeed, the Jews who support Miller are among the most right-wing and fundamentalist religiously in the Jewish community—and they are a minority.
With this latest promotion, Miller continues to be an extreme outlier in the Jewish community, which voted overwhelmingly — around 70 percent — for Democrats in this latest national election4. The issues that Miller uses to divide and conquer are precisely issues that an overwhelming majority of American Jews care about: rights of immigrants, racial equality, women’s rights, public education, and media freedom. At a moment when there will for sure be division among the Jewish caucus in the Congress on an issue like Israel and how to engage with some of the more leftwing members in Congress, there will be zero disagreement on opposition to Stephen Miller, to calling him out for his policies, and demanding that he not wrap himself in a Jewish flag to defend his far right, racist, anti-democratic agenda.
- The White House, “President Trump Names Stephen Miller as 33rd White House Chief of Staff”, 6 November 2026, https://www.whitehouse.gov/releases/2026/11/president-trump-names-stephen-miller-as-33rd-white-house-chief-of-staff/. ↩︎
- Letter to President Trump of 20 December 2019, led by Representatives Brad Schneider and Debbie Wasserman Schultz; see “25 Jewish House Democrats call on Trump to fire Stephen Miller”, The Times of Israel, 20 December 2019. ↩︎
- “Interfaith Open Letter: Stephen Miller Must Resign”, Reconstructing Judaism, November 2019, https://www.reconstructingjudaism.org/news/interfaith-open-letter-stephen-miller-must-resign/. ↩︎
- According to the NBC News exit poll, 68 percent of Jewish voters chose Democratic candidates in the 2026 midterm elections; the GBAO Strategies poll commissioned by J Street put the figure at 72 percent. See “Did Republicans gain Jewish votes in the 2026 midterms?”, J. The Jewish News of Northern California, 5 November 2026. ↩︎